Neurol India Home 

Year : 2015  |  Volume : 63  |  Issue : 1  |  Page : 122--123

Spinal lipoma with tibial hemimelia-incidental or causative? Revisiting the McCredie-McBride hypothesis

Prasad Krishnan1, Sutirtha Chakraborty2,  
1 Department of Neurosurgery, National Neurosciences Centre, Calcutta, West Bengal, India
2 Peerless Hospital and B. K Roy Research Centre, Calcutta, West Bengal, India

Correspondence Address:
Prasad Krishnan
Department of Neurosurgery, National Neurosciences Centre, Calcutta, West Bengal

How to cite this article:
Krishnan P, Chakraborty S. Spinal lipoma with tibial hemimelia-incidental or causative? Revisiting the McCredie-McBride hypothesis.Neurol India 2015;63:122-123

How to cite this URL:
Krishnan P, Chakraborty S. Spinal lipoma with tibial hemimelia-incidental or causative? Revisiting the McCredie-McBride hypothesis. Neurol India [serial online] 2015 [cited 2021 May 6 ];63:122-123
Available from:

Full Text


A 32-year-old female with congenitally short left lower limb [Figure 1] who was able to independently ambulate with a crutch presented to the Department of Orthopedics for lower limb prosthesis. Her radiographs revealed a Type-1 left tibial hemimelia and a dysplastic femur with a poorly developed femoral head and acetabulum [Figure 2]. Hence, a custom-made lower limb prosthesis with a pelvic support was planned. On examination, it was found that there was a tuft of hair in her lower back [Figure 1] for which a neurosurgical opinion was sought. On examination, she was continent with no sphincteric dysfunction. The power was normal in the right lower limb with normal reflexes. The left lower limb was flail although some movement was present at all joints. There was no sensory deficit in the limbs or in the perianal region. There was a varus deformity of the foot [Figure 1]. X-rays of the lumbosacral (LS) spine showed multilevel spina bifida [Figure 2]. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of the LS spine showed an intraspinal lipoma at D11 to L1 levels [Figure 3]. This was present more on the left side and the cord too was thinned out on the left side [Figure 3]. The ultrasound abdomen revealed normal kidneys and bladder with no evidence of residual post-void urine. No surgery was performed but her family was counseled about the possibility of neurological deterioration in the future and the patient was told to review periodically in the Neurosurgery Department.{Figure 1}{Figure 2}{Figure 3}

Tibial hemimelia is a rare congenital abnormality with an incidence of one in 1,000,000 live births. [1] It can be of four types [1] -with a complete absence of the tibia, as in our case, being classified as Type-1. While it can be associated with several other congenital abnormalities, the commonest spinal problem reported with dysmelia is scoliosis. [2] We encountered one report describing its association with hemivertebrae [1] and the other with a spinal lipoma. [3]

The influence of the development of the neural crest on limb morphogenesis came to light in experimental studies in the wake of the thalidomide disaster where it was noticed that ultrastructural changes predating the development of limb formation appeared in those dorsal root ganglia and their neurons that corresponded to the deformed limb segments. [4],[5] This theory of "embryonic sensory neuropathy" [6] contributing to the genesis of dysmelia is called the McCredie-McBride hypothesis.

The vital question in our case was whether the lipoma had contributed to the dysmelia by interfering with the functions of the dorsal horn cells; or, was it an incidental finding? It is worth noting that the side of the limb deformity and the side of the lipoma were the same (i.e., the left side). Moreover, the lipoma was posteriorly placed, i.e., in the region where the dorsal columns of the spinal cord should have been present and the MRI also showed asymmetrical cord atrophy (more on the left side). Furthermore, the location of the lipoma at D11 to L1 vertebral segments on the left side corresponded to the cord segments innervating the dysmelic lower limb.

However, the incidence of spinal lipoma is far more common (1 in 4,000 patients) [7] than that of hemimelia; and, while spinal lipomas may cause tethering or pressure effect on the cord, they have not been reported to completely replace the neural tissue or cause gross agenesis of the nerves. In fact, the cord-lipoma junction is said to be medial to the dorsal root entry zone. [8] Hence, an explanation of lipoma-induced dysgenesis of posterior columns leading to dysmelia may not be tenable (unlike in cases with thalidomide toxicity) and their association, in this case, may merely be a random occurrence of two unrelated congenital abnormalities.


1Salinas-Torres VM, Barajas-Barajas LO, Perez-Garcia N, Perez-Garcia G. Bilateral tibial hemimelia type 1 (1a and 1b) with T9 and T10 hemivertebrae: A novel association. Sao Paulo Med J 2013;131:275-8.
2Powers TA, Haher TR, Devlin VJ, Spencer D, Millar EA. Abnormalities of the spine in relation to congenital upper limb deficiencies. J Pediatr Orthop 1983;3:471-4.
3Sanyal SK, Mahapatra AK. Transverse hemimelia in a child with spinal dysraphism. Pediatr Neurosurg 2004;40:203-4.
4McBride WG. Studies of the etiology of thalidomide dysmorphogenesis. Teratology 1976;14:71-87.
5Stokes PA, Lykke WJ, McBride WG. Ultrastructural changes in the dorsal root ganglia evoked by thalidomide in rabbits. Experientia 1976;32:597-9.
6McCredie J. Segmental embryonic peripheral neuropathy. Pediatr Radiol 1975;3:162-8.
7Wykes V, Desai D, Thompson DN. Asymptomatic lumbosacral lipomas-a natural history study. Childs Nerv Syst 2012;28:1731-9.
8Chapman PH. Congenital intraspinal lipomas: Anatomic considerations and surgical treatment. Childs Brain 1982;9:37-47.